12 February
2007

DRM No More?

What the heck is he talking about?

Do you know what Digital Rights Management (DRM) is?  Well, you should.  Its the annoying part of digital media (music, DVD, whatever) that prevents the files from being copied.  I do not need to copy music so that I can obtain music without paying for it.  That would be stealing.  Which is wrong.  I need to be able to copy the music that I paid for without running into copy protection.  If the major music labels had their way, they would want me to pay for each copy of a song that I have.  So if I had the original CD, then ripped it into MP3s, then copied it to another computer and an MP3 player, those music labels think I should pay for the same song four times! 

In my typical music situation, I find a CD that I like, then buy it.  Eventually, I "rip" that CD into MP3s.  I then copy those MP3s to my home computer, my work computer and my iPod.  Simple enough, except I limit myself to CDs that I like in their entirety.  Its not worth it to me to buy a CD with one or two songs on it that I like, so I sift through CD after CD finding one that has multiple likable songs.  The obvious solution to this problem is to buy songs individually on the Internet, but most of those songs are locked down with the aforementioned DRM.  So if I do buy a single online, I run into obstacles using the music I paid for in the manner of my choosing on devices that I own.  What happens is that I get annoyed with the process and when faced with a decision to buy, I usually choose NOT to buy the music.

With Steve Jobs' recent declaration that music should be free (of DRM), the music labels are finally taking notice.  EMI (one of the major four music labels) is about to open up a majority of their music library, providing DRM-less music.  If labels begin providing music without DRM, I would be more likely to buy, whereas I would not have with DRM.  This would be a situation where removing restrictions would enhance sales.  There is value in music.  People are willing to pay for it.  However, people do not respond well to restriction.


Posted by steve at 09:25 | Comments (3) | Trackbacks (0)
Re: DRM No More?

I don't have a good solution to this, but I'd certainly be interested in a convenient online system that doesn't treat me like a potential felon.

The two options I've thought of are:
1) Buying from half.com and ripping the CD
2) Buying from itunes, burning the music as a CD and then ripping the CD.

#1 means I have total control over the music, but it's probably a little pricier.
#2 means the MP3s I eventually create will not be as high fidelity as #1

Both of these are inconvenient...

Posted by: Daniel Fisher at February 12,2007 10:10
Re: DRM No More?

Another option to consider is the Used CD route. Instead of going to some sketchy music store to sort through someone else's trash, you may want to try Amazon's Used CD section. I think every CD on Amazon has a Used CD option. Depending on how popular the music is determines how pricey it is. Newer and more popular music will not have a significant discount, whereas older music out of the mainstream may be available for a couple of bucks. (I bought a CD this way once that cost more to ship than to buy. $2 total)

Posted by: steve at February 13,2007 07:58
Re: DRM No More?

Looks like Yahoo is getting in on the new DRM-less initiative.

http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20070213-8830.html

Posted by: steve at February 13,2007 12:52
Trackbacks
Please send trackback to:
There are no trackback.
Post a comment










Prevent spam - use this code to post